Based on the comments by the judges, Haley Reinhart should be the most concerned among the eight remaining singers on American Idol.
The three judges totally trashed her singing and if Haley goes home it will be because of the comments by the judges. It is like they want Lauren Alaina Suddeth to be only female singer remaining.
Casey Abrams version of the 64 year old song Nature Boy may be great for a lounge act, but can’t see anyone going out and buying an album with that song in it.
My personal opinion is that Haley, Paul and Stefano will be in the bottom three but wouldn’t be surprised to see Jacob in the final three, because of Paul receiving the votes of legions of Twilight fans.
The poll question asks to check the singer most likely to go home on Thursday night based on their performance and the judge’s reaction to their performance on Wednesday night: